Even younger nightshift workers shown to need to pee more, worsening quality of life
Millions of people work nights, but increasingly scientists are finding that night work is associated with health problems. Now a group of Italian scientists has found that nightshift workers also need to pee more, leading to a deteriorating quality of life for many workers, including care workers. This is also true of younger subjects, who would not normally be expected to report an overactive bladder. This work is reported at the European Association of Urology Congress in Barcelona.
Researchers from the Sant’Andrea Hospital in Rome surveyed 68 men and 68 women between March and October 2018. All were workers in the Italian National Health System, with 66 of the volunteers working nightshifts, on average, 11 hours per night shift. The 70 day workers worked an average of 9.1 hours/day. The researchers found that the night shift workers reported a significantly higher rate of overactive bladder, and a poorer quality of life when compared with day shift workers. All the workers were under 50 years old.
Using the generally accepted Overactive Bladder Questionnaire*, they found that those on night shift reported an average total score of 31, as against a score of 19 for those working day shifts. They also found that night workers scored a significantly worse quality of life (measured using the OAB QL score and the EORTC QLQ-30 score), with scores of 41 against 31 with day shift workers (see abstract for ranges).
Research leader, Dr Cosimo De Nunzio said: “We know that long-term night work is stressful, and is associated with increased levels of health problems. This work shows that constant night workers may have a higher urinary frequency as well as a decline in their own quality of life. Furthermore, we have measured these changes in health workers, who are themselves responsible for looking after the well-being of patients. If they feel bad themselves, then this will inevitably lead to poorer patient care. The same is probably true in many other occupations. One of the most concerning things about this work is everyone in our sample was under 50. We normally expect bladder problems with older people, but here we have younger people expressing a deteriorating quality of life.”
In many countries, night shift work is increasing to cope with the demands of the 24-hour economy. In the UK one worker in 8 works night shift (2017 figures; that’s 3.2 million, a 250,000 increase in the previous 5 years), with one in 6 black workers working night shifts. In the USA, nearly 9 million people work night shifts. In general, night shift workers are concentrated in poorer manual or service jobs, such as security, transport, cleaning, maintenance, etc. Night work has been shown to put stresses on health, with night workers showing greater levels of depression, cardiovascular disease, and certain cancers***.
Commenting, Professor Jean-Nicolas Cornu (Rouen, France ) said: “Increased urinary frequency is an issue for millions of people worldwide. In nightshift workers, the present work highlights the importance of this issue regarding quality of life. Whether the changes described in this study depend on confounding factors (modification of drinking habits, caffeine intake, etc.) and/or modification of urinary production by the kidney cannot be assessed. A lot of work remains needed to understand what happens in those cases.”
This is an independent comment; Professor Jean-Nicolas Cornu was not involved in this work
The researchers note that this is a modest sample size, so the work needs to be reproduced in a larger study, with a longer-term follow-up.
*See https://www.baus.org.uk/_userfiles/pages/files/Patients/Leaflets/ICIQ-OAB.pdf for an example of the Overactive Bladder Questionnaire
**See https://qol.eortc.org/ for the EORTC-30 questionnaire
UK figures https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/night-shift-workers-rise-numbers-uk-tuc-260000-five-years-a8022806.html
US Figures https://www.webmd.com/sleep-disorders/features/shift-work#1
Funding: there was no external funding for this work.
Night shift workers have a higher overactive bladder score with an impairment of quality of life: A prospective cohort study
De Nunzio C. , Cicione A. , Nacchia A. , Tema G. , Sarchi L. , D'Annunzio S. , Trucchi A. , Tubaro A.
Sapienza University of Rome, Sant'Andrea Hospital, Dept. of Urology, Rome, Italy
Introduction & Objectives
Recent studies suggest that night shift jobs may have adverse health effects on several anatomical systems through the developing of sleep disorders. Up to now, little is known about the impact of night work on lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS). The present study was aimed to evaluate the impact of night shift work on patients’ urinary symptoms.
Materials & Methods
Between March 2018 to October 2018, an internal survey was carried out by enrolling subjects working in a national healthcare system and performing night shifts or traditional work hours (from6am to2pm). All the subjects were asked to compile namelessly the following international validated questionnaires: Overactive Bladder Questionnaire (OABq), and European Organization for the Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire (EORTC QLQ-C30). Furthermore, clinical variables were collected too (i.e. age and medical history). Then, collected data were analyzed in according to being night shift worker (NSWs) or traditional workers (TWs) through descriptive methods. Univariate and multivariate analysis was performed.
A total of 136 participants, (68 male and 68 females) 40±10 years old were included in the survey. A mean BMI of 23.3±2.7 was computed. All subjects did notrefer chronic disease and drugs therapy. Among them, 66 were NSWs with a mean of 11±1.5 work hours per night and 13±4.6 day hours per week. Seventy subjects were TWs with a mean of 9.1±1.9 hours per day and 46.7±10.5 hours per week. On OABq, total score, symptoms bother and QoL domains were significantly (p<0.05) higher in NSWs group, respectively: 31 IQR 26-35 Vs 19 IQR 19-20; 11 IQR 10-13 Vs 6 IQR 6-7; 19 IQR 16-22 Vs 13 13-14. Likewise, individuals performing night shifts reported significative higher median score than TWs on EORTC QLQ-C30 (41; IQR 34-46 Vs 31; IQR 27-35). Finally, seven NSWs (10.6%) referred nocturia respect to only one (1%) TWs, (p=0.02). On multivariate analysis NSWs was an independent predictors of OABq> 30 units (OR:30; CI: 9-111, p=0.001).
Our analysis showed that healthy subjects less than 50 years old performing night shift works suffer presented worst OAB symptoms and poor QL when compared to similar traditional workers. Long term data onNSWs patients are also needed to further clarify this relationship
Related news and insights
The digital ILC 2020 recently brought together over ten thousand scientific and medical professionals from a broad range of fields for three days of virtual sessions, ePosters and plenaries. If you couldn’t make it, catch-up with our highlights from this year’s congress.